Molly Sicard

3 months ago

"I love this place! Beautiful pieces that were carefully picked. Josie (@shypony) was amazing and helpful. She encouraged me to try things on without any pressure to buy anything. I ended up loving what I got and will never forget my experience here. I am newly becoming interested in fashion and this felt like a very safe space free of judgement. Thank you so much 💖"

Cal Zito

4 months ago

"fantastic vintage store (lol) with even cooler owners. i can’t go there all the time but when i do it’s wonderful. very calming inside! my gf just bought a shirt from here recently and it’s in her constant rotation. ten out of ten start ⭐️"

tabitha thompson

a year ago

"Amazing selection of beautifully hand picked vintage pieces!! Josie (@shypony) is the most amazing human being with such an eye for fun and special vintage clothes!! you won't regret checking out her selection"

Ellen Greene

a year ago

"Jamie (Poorly Curated) has been slinging my favorite vintage for years, pretty much every thing I purchase from her ends up being something I treasure. I was thrilled when she opened her brick and mortar in collab with a fellow vintage genius. Every piece in the shop is truly delightful, distinct, and timeless and reminds you why shopping vintage can be so special. If you go to one vintage store in NYC make it this one, I promise."

Adam Z

a year ago

"Beautiful shop! Filled with stunning & unique designer garments - the owners were very kind & helpful in picking out a gift for my girlfriend"