Laura Sandler

3 weeks ago

"Great independent designer vintage. Brian was so helpful, I picked out 2 prada dresses, a Margiela dress, and an Ivan Grundahl dress. They are all magnificent."

Lucy Ewert

a month ago

"Pilgrim is the BEST. Richard and Brian have curated the most beautiful selection of clothing I have ever seen - and are SO knowledgeable about all things fashion!! Cannot recommend enough 😇🫶"

Olivia Campbell

3 months ago

"This is an Anti mask establishment (with a hint of racial profiling). Was told I couldn’t mask in store by the front desk guy who reviews seem to have issues with as well. He said that it’s a common policy (it isn’t, no other thrift store or clothing store has ever asked me to unmask, from Prada to L train vintage). At most a face flash is necessary. Very disappointed because from what I saw of the selection it looked promising."

Teresa Berggren

6 months ago

"Fantastic curation of very lovely pieces. Love this place. If in NY, make this the place to buy yourself something. Top labels, great selection and very fair prices. Staff is helpful but not pushy. Always come back."

Jillian Hosier

9 months ago

"Pilgrim is one of the most special places in the city! Their collection is absolutely beautiful. Always fresh and thoughtfully curated. Chatting with the owners always makes my day. You can tell they have a wealth of experience and are so passionate about fashion. I recently purchased my new favorite staple piece with the help of the friendly staff. Don’t miss this gem!"