Budi Kurniawan

2 weeks ago

"Fantastic Italian restaurant. Very friendly & hospitable hosts of manager to service staffs. Great food: NY strip, Chicken Parm, Veal Marsala, Spaghetti Meatball all came out great. Tiramisu was excellent. Definitely worth the visit and will come by again."

shakiya phillips

a month ago

"Each time I’ve walked past since their re-opening it has appeared nearly packed, and seeing their reviews we were excited to try it out given there aren’t many other large restaurants in the neighbourhood. However after visiting we are left pretty confused. We tried the dishes people most seem to rave about (Caesar, chicken parm, and lasagna) and overall the food was very average (honestly more likely below average for nyc). The Caesar salad was by far the best, but it’s not hard to do a good Caesar. The lasagna and chicken parm were both very lacking in flavour, and both featured a sort of soggy texture - overcooked noodles in the lasagna was probably a factor. The chicken in the parm was rough and tough and the crumb was soggy underneath a dousing of bland sauce and cheese. And for very average food, the prices were above average - the lasagna and chicken parm were both $40 each. Service seemed frantic - I appreciate it was very busy but it still took around 10 minutes of being seated just to get a menu and water. Given this, maybe they were understaffed for their demand that night and this had an effect on the quality of the food, but overall I wouldn’t come back."

Devon Singer

a month ago

"Nearly a year and a half of anticipating, I went first night back, nothing’s changed! Still the best Caesar salad and best shrimp scampi ever! They also have the best cottage fried potato chips and lasagna. Top-tier chicken and veal Parm. All the Italian Classics on top of that. Billy Bruckman and his staff I’m so glad to see you all again. My parents have been going since 1981. I was born in 1992. So let’s just say Pietro’s is very close to our hearts."

Michelle Wills

2 months ago

"So thrilled our favorite establishment is back and better than ever. Pietro’s remains an enduring New York institution that continues to set the standard for timeless Italian dining. Every detail, from the service to the execution, reflects true culinary craftsmanship. The Caesar salad is nothing short of legendary: crisp romaine, impeccably balanced dressing, and just the right touch of Parmesan. It is perfection in its simplicity and truly the best Caesar salad in the world. The Red Snapper Marechiaro is a masterpiece. The fish is delicately prepared, accompanied by clams and a fragrant tomato wine sauce that captures the essence of the Amalfi coast. It embodies elegance and comfort in equal measure and is pure chef’s kiss. Perhaps most impressive, Pietro’s maintains this same level of excellence even in delivery. The quality, flavor, and presentation travel flawlessly, offering the same exceptional experience you enjoy in the restaurant. Pietro’s is not just a meal; it is a reminder of why classic Italian cuisine, when done right, never goes out of style."

Stacy P

2 years ago

"Love this family style Italian restaurant! The ambiance made us feel at home. And the food and service was excellent. We liked all the dishes we ordered. Highly recommend their generously portioned lasagna. Great history of loyal customers… I can see why it’s a favorite place for many local New Yorkers and families. We will be back again soon."