Kristie Ang

a week ago

"This is a fantastic spot for a classic Italian meal, especially when dining with a group. The location is ideal as it is right in the heart of Times Square and easy to get to, making it a convenient meeting place. The atmosphere is warm, lively, and inviting, with that old-school Italian charm that makes you feel comfortable and ready to settle in for a great meal. We loved that the menu is served family-style, which made it easy and fun to order a variety of dishes to share. The menu offers all the Italian classics you’d hope for, and everything we ordered was absolutely delicious, with very generous portions. Be sure to leave room for dessert, as it’s just as good as the main courses. Overall, Tony’s Di Napoli delivers great food, a fun atmosphere, and an excellent experience for groups. We’d definitely return the next time we’re in the city."

Shamus Williams

2 weeks ago

"This was a great place to eat. We had to wait despite the reservation, but it's NYC, so we expected it to be busy. Once seated, the servers came to the table quickly. Speaking of which, the servers were efficient and professional. The dishes were all excellent, exactly what you'd expect from a classic Italian restaurant. Plus, we have gluten free restrictions and they didn't even flinch. I definitely recommend it."

Nooran Ostadeian

2 weeks ago

"Dining at Tony's Di Napoli was truly one of the most fun and memorable stops on our New York trip. The restaurant has a beautiful, classic Italian setup and design that instantly gives you the feeling of being in Italy. I loved the walls covered with photos of so many famous people, it adds so much character and history to the place. The food was fairly good, though for me it felt more Americanized than truly authentic Italian. That said, the portions are absolutely massive. Whatever you order, keep in mind that at least three people can easily share one dish and feel completely full. The atmosphere is outstanding, but the absolute best part of this place is the staff. They are incredible, so friendly, fun to talk to, and clearly experienced with guests from all over the world. Their energy, warmth, and sense of humor made our visit even more enjoyable. We truly enjoyed the conversations and the overall vibe. This was definitely one of our best stops in New York."

Felipe Franzini

3 weeks ago

"The restaurant has a lively atmosphere and a classic Italian-American vibe, which fits well with the busy Times Square area. It can get crowded and noisy, but that’s expected for the location. The food was good and served in large family-style portions, which is great for sharing. Some dishes stood out more than others, but everything we tried was fresh and flavorful. Prices are a bit on the higher side, though understandable given the area. Service was generally friendly and efficient, even with the restaurant being very busy. We didn’t feel rushed, and the staff handled the crowd well. Overall, Tony’s Di Napoli is a good option if you’re around Times Square and want classic Italian comfort food with generous portions. Not the best Italian spot I’ve ever been to, but definitely a reliable and enjoyable choice."

J K

a month ago

"We did not have to wait very long for the food to come out. But when it did come, the food was not very hot. We ordered a rigatoni a la vodka and the pasta was really overcooked and chewy, so it just tasted like hardened pasta with sauce. The portion sizes for the appetizer and the pasta (full) were sufficient for 2 people. The service was okay, we felt that the waiter kept returning too often to ask if we were done when we obviously weren't. The peach bellini was delicious."