Luis cruceta

a month ago

"Overall experience was a 10/10! Tried the Buffalo chicken slice (7.8/10) — super good, amazing crust, just wish it had a little more ranch. The pepperoni slice was 8/10, fresh and delicious. Great pizza, great service — definitely recommend Little Italy Pizzeria & Deli! 🍕"

Corey Pisapia

a month ago

"Sadly, big time fan moving on here. Recently found that this location hides receipts, and doesn’t give refunds when orders are made wrong. I’ve been going there for six years and with one night of mean attitudes and shady answers regarding tips and receipts, I’ll be avoiding this business moving forward. Would’ve been a $10.00 refund. They also asked me to bring the old pizza back the next day. So here’s the proof I’ll be returning it in the box tomorrow."

S. Ros

3 months ago

"Their pizza was actually delicious. We were craving classic NYC slices but were too tired to head to one of the top-rated spots. To our surprise, this 4.3-rated place served absolutely amazing pizza — perfectly crunchy on the bottom, flavorful, and truly satisfying. Really good, definitely recommend."

gary a. wexler

6 months ago

"Nice big selection of pies. Good sauce and flavors. The crust is neither thin or thick, but has an airy, light but crunchy feel. The prices are not outrageous like most of Manhattan, but more in line with outer boros and Long Island, maybe even cheaper. Counter guys are nice. I like the bright red tiled walls in the dining area. Convenient to South Street Seaport."

Christopher Z

7 months ago

"The Sicilian Pepperoni slice here looked appetizing, so I tried one. It's overflowing with scrumptious pepperoni, the sauce is great, the cheese is fantastic, and the crust at the end was very good. All factors of the slice were perfect. Try it!"