M Ortiz (Epicurean Explorer Rater)

a week ago

"Lady Mendl’s Tea Salon is a charming step back in time. Set inside a historic townhouse, the atmosphere is elegant and serene, perfect for a leisurely afternoon tea. The traditional tea service is beautifully presented, with fresh finger sandwiches, warm scones with clotted cream, and classic pastries. The tea selection is excellent, and everything is served with care and unhurried grace. Service is attentive without being intrusive. Ideal for special occasions or a quiet escape from the city."

Shelby Builta

2 weeks ago

"Talk about a hidden gem! My mom surprised us on a trip to New York with a table at Lady Mendl's. We had a beautiful 5 course tea time with finger sandwiches, deserts, scones and paired teas for tasting. The leek potato soup was so good that I dream about it at night! If you have time or enjoy relaxing in the Big city, I HIGHLY recommend"

Patricia Beja

5 months ago

"Fabulous afternoon tea in a brownstone at Irving Place. Beautiful, eclectic decor with lovely mismatched furniture and tea services. Mostly vegetarian options to indulge in sharing with your friends. One of my go to places to bring out of towners for this tea experience. I love the course tea pairings. The server, Valeria, is amazing. Their Lady M later crepe cake is divine."

Meenu Jandra

5 months ago

"I had high expectations given the price tag of $100 per person ($89+ tax+tip) But it was quite underwhelming experience in terms of overall presentation, quality and quantity of food. 1. We had a prior reservation for 4 people but we got the table quite late because they were full. Portion size should be mentioned in the menu. 2. We were given table in a small dimly lit room on the other side (looked like extra room). 3. We were started with seasonal soup which was basically Cilantro chutney in a very tiny glass (green chutney that we get with samosa) 4. You will get 5 finger sandwiches per person. Since 3 of us were non meat eaters, we requested replacement with vegetarian options but were denied. Honestly the sandwiches were quite boring and worst quality of all food. 5. They brought 4-5 types of teas. They were okay. 6. Then they served scones with jam and clotted cream. You get 2 per person. Scones were good and everyone enjoyed them. 7. You will get one chocolate covered strawberry, one macaron and one petit square dessert per person. I wouldn’t pay more than $20-$30 for such food. There are so many better places in New York City for high tea with better experience for same or much less price tag. Later we did take few pictures in the main sitting area which had much better ambience. Avoid back room."

Ames “TheGoogleReviewer” PA

5 months ago

"A lovely 5 course afternoon tea. Favorites were the butternut squash and boursin cheese, goat cheese and fig sandwiches, the scones were delicious and the spicy watermelon soup was outrageous. the vanilla crepe cake was one of the best desserts we ever had."