Abe F

5 months ago

"I’ve been a customer for years and hesitant to leave a feedback because I’m a regular customer but what’s the purpose of feedbacks if I’m not leaving one. Their food is always good, but their service is consistently bad. Their food is always good, but their service is consistently bad. There’s obviously an issue. Today I had the luxury to get Eli on the phone and he was well trained employee to be rude. It seems to be the common theme there."

Benjamin Helwa

5 months ago

"Holy Schnitzel never misses! I’ve been here a few times already, and the food is always flavorful and fresh. This time, I got the Holy Toasty sandwich and the Grilled Chicken Avocado Wrap, and both were excellent. The Holy Toasty is one of my all-time favorites—crispy chicken, grilled pastrami, honey mustard, and holy sauce all toasted together on a warm baguette. The flavors just work perfectly together—crispy, smoky, sweet, and tangy in every bite. The Grilled Chicken Avocado Wrap was a great balance—lighter, but still filling. The chicken was juicy and tender, and the avocado added a nice creamy touch. Definitely a solid go-to when you want something satisfying but not too heavy. Service was quick and friendly as always. Whether you’re craving comfort food or something a bit cleaner, they’ve got great options. One of my top spots on Staten Island for sure."

Nora M

5 months ago

"⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ The Holy Toasty sandwich lives up to its name — crispy, flavorful, and totally satisfying 😇🔥. I also really enjoyed the chicken avocado wrap — fresh, filling, and full of flavor 🥑🍗. Service was quick, staff was friendly, and the sauce bar had tons of options to mix things up 👌. Everything came out hot, packed well, and in generous portions. Out of all the Holy Shnitzel locations I’ve been to, this Staten Island spot is definitely one of my favorites. Great quality, great energy — I’ll be back soon! 🙌🥪🍟"

Daneen Gentile

a year ago

"We ordered for the first time from Holy Schnitzel to celebrate a coworkers birthday. The order cost over $200 and were totally dissapointed. Dispite our excitement to try their kosher cuisine, the food was a total let down and unable to be eaten. The chicken was raw, not undercooked. The order took an hour and a half to receive after the person taking the order asked if we could get them the order by 10:45. The burger was like cardboard and the pastrami was lets say disgusting!! I would pay the toll and take a short trip to Harolds for my next kosher meal next time. Out of 12 orders placed not one was happy with their order."

Avraham Schwartz

2 years ago

"The food is scrumptious! Ordered The Holy Toasty and a Popcorn Chicken Rice Bowl. Had place to sit, it was nice and warm. Definitely returning. Thanks! Add on: I'm a returning customer and I'm impressed with the service. The food is out of this world!"