Sasha Baumrind

a week ago

"I have been going here since it opened 25+ years ago. This is the only place where the fish is consistently so fresh and good that all it needs is salt and pepper and the price is 1000% worth it. To top it off, the staff could not be nicer or more helpful. Chris and Jose are the absolute best and their new space looks great."

Mathias Zillich

a week ago

"The owner Topher is very nice. Was looking to place a large order for a party I have coming up and he helped me pick out good fish to cook. His staff also helped me look up recipes to use!"

Cass

2 months ago

"The poke bowl is decent but a bit strange lol. On non-sticky short grain rice. With avocado and radish and scallion and celery. Not seaweed and cucumber and the typical toppings. It was pretty fast! And they’re nice."

King Boreqwa

9 months ago

"Currently getting ready for a bodybuilding show, so what does that mean? I need to find the best QUALITY FISH IN BROOKLYN. Shoutout to the team there, especially Chris and Jose for having the best fish on deck whenever you need it. Fresh fish that NEVER SMELLS, and DONT GET ME STARTED FOR THE POL BOYS! Not only just for meal preps, but even for get togethers! This is more than your typical fish market. ITS THEEEEE FISH MARKET 💪🏽🙏🏽🐟"

Reid Andrés

2 years ago

"Fish Tales is top-notch! I've been a customer for 10+ years and this place never disappoints. From line-caught striped bass and flounder from LI, to langoustines, tuna steaks, cockles, and soft shell crabs... the product is always ultra fresh and delicious. Nick, Chris, Jose, and team behind the scenes deliver, time and again. Great seafood that's well worth the visit. 10/10."