John T

a week ago

"Best Pizza in New York Penn Station, hands down. Always fresh. Fast moving, action packed place. Cool vibe. I always pop in for a bite whenever I pass by."

Janet

2 months ago

"The Hispanic female cashier working 10-18-25 was rude. I wanted clarification of the final cost of my purchase . She behaved as if I had no right to ask . Not the first time I’ve had a bad experience purchasing pizza here. Rampant since the new presidential administration that the Hispanic people elected."

L

3 months ago

"I’ll make a few things clear: 1. Yes the pizza is amazing 2. Yes some slices are hit or miss 3. Just don’t order the hit or miss slices Best slices: Meatball, Sausage, White Pizza, Buffalo Chicken, Pesto. For some reason the cheese and pepperoni slices do not feel or taste the same as others. With that being said, go for the chunky slices (but the Sicilians are sometimes undercooked in the middle, dry on top). So anything triangular and thicc are a must have. But again, 5 stars because the good slices are outstandingly awesome. I literally cannot stop coming here. One slice is filling, and can’t complain about the price."

Prashanth Shetty

10 months ago

"Don Pepi Pizza in New York Penn station is located in the right place for quickly grabbing a slice before you dash to catch a train. I had a slice of Chicken Parm. It was delicious 😋. I had never had chicken parm which was so crispy outside and so soft inside. I was relishing each and every bite. The staff is quick... A bunch of people taking orders, one of them ringing the transaction, the only time you wait is for the pizza to be heated.. There are vegetarian options as well."

Xio

a year ago

"The pizza here is so good and fresh. The crust is thin and crispy. I've gone to many pizzerias in NY, and they've all disappointed me except for this one. Many of the pizzerias have weird toppings and unappealing dough except for this one. This is the holy grail right here. The sauce they have is magical it is so good. If you're hungry for pizza and you're in the station, you need to stop by."