Paul McConnell

a month ago

"Best seafood in the area. Always helpful with ideas for recipes."

Peter DeVincenzo

8 months ago

"The quality is incredible. Everything is so fresh. Their salmon is fantastic; their fluke is dependably great; their fish cakes make for a delicious lazy weeknight dinner. This is a family owned / family run spot that is a resource and an institution in the neighborhood."

Ron A

11 months ago

"I have been shopping here for years. Mike and his staff are extremely professional, knowledgeable and personable. Every piece of fish purchased has been as fresh as if it just came out of the ocean. Store is spotless and doesn’t have that “fish smell’ that is common in other establishments. Prices are very competitive and quality is second to none."

Anthony Tringali

a year ago

"Bravo once again! Wish Christmas Eve was every evening. Why stop at 7 fishes when going to this old school fish market. A rare find in Brooklyn. Everything fresh with great prices."

Trope

a year ago

"I travel from the Bensonhurst section of Brooklyn to Cosentino's in Bay Ridge because the fish stores by me have changed for the worse. Luckily I found Cosentino's...this place is super clean, the fish is very fresh, and the staff is very nice. I would definitely recommend coming here."