Reed Zimmermann

2 months ago

"Nice food, very attentive service. Paneer makhani was too sweet for my taste but everything else was great! Nice ambiance too. Also very accommodating for my cashew allergy."

K D

2 months ago

"We tried the Malai Kabob in Appetizer and had the Daal,Chicken korma and Paneer Makhani in the main dish Portions were good and the food was very tasty Definitely recommend this place is you in the Williamsburg /Brooklyn area"

Maria Braganza

4 months ago

"In the mood for vegetarian?? Then Atithi is a must-visit! Have been meaning to come here since last year & finally made the trip! The chaats were blasts of flavour activating all 5 senses! The warm onion kulcha with the Paneer Bhatti masala was a dhaba like experience. The Bhature we ate as an accompaniment as my Mom couldn't eat Choley! The pillowy bread didn't disappoint! Finished the meal with halwa and Kulfi Falooda! For drinks we chose the masala sodas, which was refreshing and detoxifying thru the rich meal! The service was friendly & warm! Kudos to Deepak who makes the time to visit every table suggesting meals & specialties!"

Luke Skywalker

5 months ago

"Great food, welcoming staff. The food was fresh, tasty. They had the prefix menu as well which comes with appetizers, entree and a dessert. They even made vegetarian option as Green chilli Paneer for my veg friend when requested. Great portions. I definitely recommend this place!"

Ruth Retiz

6 months ago

"A hidden gem with bold flavors and warm hospitality. This small, cozy restaurant has a relaxed vibe, made vibrant by traditional Indian décor that adds colorful touches throughout the space. The service was excellent—friendly and incredibly fast. We were welcomed with refreshments the moment we sat down and treated to complimentary poppers served with two flavorful chutneys: mint and tamarind. To start, we had the veggie-stuffed samosas. The portion includes two generously sized samosas, crispy on the outside and packed with seasoned vegetables on the inside, paired with green and tamarind chutney. For our mains, we ordered the chicken tikka masala and a hearty paneer dish mixed with chickpeas and potatoes in a rich masala gravy. Each came with a side of fragrant basmati rice. We also added roti and garlic naan. Overall, we really enjoyed the food, atmosphere, and service. A great spot if you’re craving flavorful Indian cuisine in a welcoming setting."