Mag Tulsi

a month ago

"A lovely Greek restaurant offering fresh and delicious food. The pita starter was very tasty. The Greek salad was to die for - fresh ingredients, feta cheese of great quality and seasoning. The lemon potatoes were a bit too firm for me. I found the dorado too dominated by the capers. Lamb Gyro and souvlaki - mouthwatering. The service was professional."

Taylor Bevis

2 months ago

"Enjoyed dinner at Anatoli last night for the first time and had a wonderful meal! I am gluten free, so the gf pita and options were so nice to have and tasted delicious. Can’t remember the last time I could eat a gyro! Looking forward to going back."

Jesse Boone

2 months ago

"Mediterranean food is my mother's favorite, and it was the biggest priority for our menu on our trip to NYC. I searched Manhattan for the right place, and Anatoli stood out right away. We loved this place. The dolmas were just right, the spanakopita just like the kind my mom likes to make, the lobster was delicious, and the moussaka was hearty. The atmosphere was so friendly, and our waitress Ana was kind. We had so many questions about the place, and despite being so busy, Ana made time to answer every one. We will definitely be back one day. Efcharistó!"

Dominick Rich

2 months ago

"Delicious! The Lamb Gyro on Gluten Free pita didn’t disappoint. The pita was light, the lamb tasty, and fries nicely spiced."

Lauren Castille

4 months ago

"I just left and already cannot wait to go back, it was SO good! They have gluten free pita bread and can use it for any of the sandwiches. The servers were really nice and helpful, too. I hadn’t had a gyro in over a decade so I’m suuuuper impressed and grateful for the GF options! Cocktails and food were both stellar."