Maggie Pie

in the last week

"The fact that they’re still charging $1.50 for a plain slice is honestly wild. What’s even crazier is that it actually tastes like a premium slice. If you’re someone who avoids cheap pizza, try this place anyway. It’ll completely change your mind. I wasn’t even planning on going in. I was waiting for someone at my hotel when a worker noticed me looking inside and waved me over. I figured, why not. Wow."

Anonymous Boo

2 weeks ago

"It was slow (7ish pm) when I visited so the pizza was cold. The seasonings provided on the counter made it manageable. After eating, my tum tum was a lil grumpy but I have been eating "healthier" so maybe I'm just over 1.50 "fresh" pizza. Paid in cash but he gave me the wrong amount back, thankfully I had done the math before so I noticed right away lol."

Paula Regan

2 weeks ago

"Voted 5 stars, I wanted cheap NY pizza and I got cheap NY pizza, it was greasy and good! Cheese is $1.50 and if you add a topping it's $2.25/$2.50."

C W

5 months ago

"I went here a few times during my stay in NYC earlier this year. Pizza was cheap, but so good!! Its a busy little spot, but if you don't mind waiting a few minutes, you can eat cheap and enjoy your meal. Highly recommend this joint. Should I ever return to the area, this will be my first stop."

Alberto Montano

5 months ago

"Excelent pizza 🍕! The flavor is very good, the service is fast and polite and the price unbeatable: 2 slices and a drink for $4. A little crowded for dine in."