Nicole Maschwitz

a week ago

"We were freezing and looking for somewhere to eat, ended up at scallywags. Ro welcomed us in, with her lovely smile and sense of humour. She went above and beyond to make us feel welcome. Service was fantastic! The shepherds pie and bangers and mash were excellent. We definitely would recommend this establishment. Live music there too, what more could you want. Thanks Ro for making this couple of Aussie chicks night with your hospitality."

Erinn Como

a month ago

"We had a nice lunch today at Scallywag’s. The beer was perfectly poured - Guinness, Black & Tan, Stella. The food was fresh and delicious. The service was friendly and attentive. We even left a bag behind, and the server made sure it got back to one of the people in our party safely. We’ll definitely be back again when we are in the area!"

John Dowd

a month ago

"Great Irish American pub. Music. Guinness. Came back for Shepards Pie and sweet potato fries."

Dr Fridolin

2 months ago

"Nice Irish bar with a good atmosphere and very friendly/attentive staff. Has good quality live music too. However, prices are on the expensive side; ~$40 including tax/tip for 3 pints feels like a lot, even considering the location (the same round at the closest bar is only $30) especially when all of the drinks were flat. Decent place to pop into but won't necessarily be visiting again."

Eitan Davis

7 months ago

"BEST GUINNESS POUR IN NYC HANDS DOWN Believe me we searched. You know you’ve reached the right place for a pint when the Irish accents outnumber the rest. We were in the area for about a week and stopped for a pint of Guinness wherever it presented itself. Many decent pints in the city. This one is the clear winner. Lucky to have Scallywags around the corner from our hotel and able to repeat often throughout our stay. Comfortable pub feel, impeccably clean lines, sparkling, cold glasses and welcoming bartenders who take care in handing out a proper pour and making you feel, honestly, at home. (Ro and Cathryn are absolute assets!) $10 *imperial* pints all day. None of the 16oz glasses being handed out for more elsewhere. Stop by. Your expectations will be exceeded."