Timothy B. Barnhill

2 weeks ago

"You can feel the history as soon as you walk in. I got there a few minutes after the opened at and the locals were already crowding in and everybody knew everyone else and it was a nice respite from the craziness outside. I had Pop Pop's top shelf burger and I would totally get it again. I chose this place because of a scene from Highlander that was filmed there but I would go back just because of who they are. Love it."

Robert Goodman

3 weeks ago

"Just a great neighborhood pub. Close to 100 years old I think. And for good reason. The staff is awesome and so are the numerous regulars. Always friendly and familiar faces in the joint. People really love the signature burger - the pop pop I think it is - but I tend to opt for the classic bacon cheeseburger. Steak fries are potentially polarizing - I cannot understand why - but that’s your default side. Can also opt for tots or onion rings. Have a nice potato salad too - really nice if they are just making it and you can get it while still warm or room temp (that’s a southern thing). It looks like they sell a lot of wings but I have to say the chicken fingers may be the best out there. Kids or no kids the fingers are tip top. Rumor has it his eminence Cardinal Dolan has been known to take a pint or two on a random afternoon as well. All the other celebrity sightings tend to be nonchalant affairs. Enjoy."

Michael G

2 months ago

"My sons were coming here regularly leisure during Covid and dragged me along a couple of years ago. I just love it. It’s about as old school New York dive bar as it gets, but the food is great, the service is fantastic and the pricing is right. I love coming here.. Our server tonight was Oscar, who is a really good representative of the place."

Marty Cegelka

6 months ago

"Very good Irish bar. Food was good and service was quick. Prices are reasonable. Pastrami sandwich was very good."

Vivianne Barretto

12 months ago

"Nice size Bar/Restaurant. I like the Old Timey feel of the place. The prices are very reasonable. I had the Chicken Fingers, which were very dry but I liked the sauces it came with. It seems like a neighborhood bar but one where everyone is welcomed. Meg is a good bartender and she's very nice and welcoming. I would come back but I would order something else."