Peggy Brueckner

2 weeks ago

"We had a great time here! Everyone was incredibly friendly, the burgers and onion rings were perfect for a cold day. Our drinks were perfectly made and the bartender was so sweet and kind. The Christmas decorations were outstanding! What a way to get inspired for the holidays!!"

Jared DeValk

2 months ago

"Great Irish Pub in NYC! I was in town for a work event and I had a day off. As a player of Irish Sports, I wanted to visit a great Irish Pub in NYC and the reviews on Reddit all pointed to Molly Shebeen's. After a stroll through Madison Park, I made it to Molly's and was greeted with a smile from the bartender. I ordered a Guinness to start and it came out cold and quick. I looked at the menu and because of the rainy day, Shepherd's Pie seemed like the ticket. My food came out in less than 10 minutes and it was hot (the bartender warned me). It was delicious and hit the spot. No BS ingredients, hearty vegetables, good size chunks of ground beef, and very delicious. I also appreciated all the Gaelic sport photos and Irish Cultural items on the walls, and not a bunch of green shamrocks and leprechauns. Thank you for the Guinness, the Shepherd's Pie, and Slainte!"

Mike D

4 months ago

"Classic Irish pub with a great menu. Had the wings and fish and chips. For the wings, received 9 drums and 1 flat. Disappointing but the drums were pretty 7.4 The fish was very moist and tend and the batter was crunchy. The tartar sauce was quit nenmmmmmmm"

Firestrike

8 months ago

"Yum! A great spot for comfort food and drinks that's open pretty late! The atmosphere is cozy and has pretty lighting, and there's both a bar and separate tables. The kitchen seems like it closes at 12am, so do keep that in mind (the bar is open quite a bit later). I got the sausage with mashed potatoes and gravy and it was delicious! The gravy was rich and flavorful, the sausage springy and juicy, and the mash teetered on the perfect balance between creamy and fluffy. Loved the onions on top too! Everything together made for some wonderful bites. A comforting and hearty meal for sure. I didn’t order any drinks this time but I would imagine that a tall glass of beer would've completed the experience. Maybe next time! Update: I came back and tried the fish and chips with a couple of beers. Also really good! The batter was crispy and the fish was tender and juicy. The tartar sauce was delicious, sweet and tangy, although I do wish it came with some more. The guiness beers had the perfect layer of foam on top of them too!"

David Chin

10 months ago

"A true gem and a delightful throwback to a bygone era! The moment you step inside, you’re instantly enveloped by the charm and rich history of this wonderful establishment. While I came for the lfish and chips, I found myself completely captivated by the incredible atmosphere. The nostalgic 70's and 80's tracks set the perfect vibe, making the experience feel both cozy and lively. The fish and chips were very good—crispy, golden, and perfectly cooked, just as you’d hope for. I also had the pleasure of trying the corned beef sandwich, which, while slightly drier than I anticipated, was still flavorful and satisfying. The real star of the meal, however, was the introduction to the English mustard—its bold, tangy kick elevated every bite and left me wanting more. This place is a must-visit for anyone seeking a memorable dining experience filled with great food, fantastic music, and a warm, welcoming ambiance. I can’t wait to return and explore more of the menu!"