Jen

a week ago

"Came to check out this spot before the Nets game. Food was good but the service sucked. Waitress never came back after we got our food. Wanted a second drink but was turned off by the horrible service and just wanted to get out of there. Had to signal for her to bring the bill. My bf left her a small tip, but if it was up to me she wouldn't have gotten nothing. First and last time there."

Jennifer Milbouer

2 weeks ago

"We had our daughter’s baptism reception in the 2nd floor event space on 12/6/25 and it was perfect for us. We had about 56 people and the space worked out so well for that amount, though it can definitely hold more. The food was delicious (chicken parm, roast beef, salad, penne, roast potatoes) and the two staff we had were amazing. It was decorated for Christmas which added a really nice festive flair to the party, and Mike’s staff were able to set out centerpieces, fake flowers, and favors that I had dropped off the night before. They were very flexible and accommodating during the planning process. We would definitely work with McMahon’s again."

Aleh Ranchynski

a month ago

"McMahon’s Public House offers a classic pub experience with a warm, old-school charm. The rich wood interior, brick walls, and vintage sports memorabilia create a cozy atmosphere perfect for relaxing with friends or catching a game. The long bar is impressive, featuring a wide lineup of draft beers and a well-stocked selection of spirits. Multiple TVs ensure you won’t miss any sports action, no matter where you sit. The dining area is spacious, with plenty of tables for larger groups, and the upstairs area adds extra room for events or busy nights. While the menu posted outside shows familiar pub favorites, the real draw here is the inviting vibe, friendly staff, and great drink selection that keeps guests coming back."

Rich Q

3 months ago

"This is a great spot, and so close to the subway and Barklay's. Bartenders are so profeasional and friendly. Real hard working people. Drinks are mixed and/or poured just right. Food wise, I only had the French fries, but they were darn good!"

Tatyana Scarlett

7 months ago

"My family and I came here to celebrate following my graduation, since it was last minute and we didn’t make reservations anywhere else. I’m so happy we did! Jerry was on staff, and was super accommodating for such a big party that just came waltzing through the door. The food was so good 🤤 and the drinks did exactly what they needed to do. We all had a great time and it was the perfect atmosphere and vibe for a laid back celebration. Thank you so much Jerry for your amazing service! (And thank you Chef for the amazing food!!) 🩵"