Rodushi

2 months ago

"I’ve been a loyal customer for a long time, but I think this will be my last visit. This isn’t the first time I’ve been disappointed with their service. In the past, they’ve forgotten to include the message I requested on my cake, and this time, the writing looked like it was done by a toddler. What made it worse is that I actually saw with my own eyes that while preparing my cake, someone accidentally touched the side of it and ruined part of the decoration. I assumed they would fix it or make a new one, but instead, they handed me the cake as it was — with a visible hand mark on the side. We spent $65–$75 on this cake and expected much better quality and professionalism. Very disappointed and unlikely to return."

Jon P.

4 months ago

"I recently stopped into Martha’s Country Bakery in Astoria and tried a few desserts. I had the Vegan Carrot Cake ($9.75 per slice), the Nutty Apple Cheesecake ($7.95), and the Pecan Cheesecake Bar ($7.95). The cheesecakes were absolutely incredible—rich, creamy, and easily some of the best I’ve ever had. That said, the price point felt a little steep for a single slice/bar, especially compared to other bakeries in the area. The Vegan Carrot Cake, on the other hand, was a bit of a letdown. The cake itself was decent, but the icing lacked that classic cream cheese flavor that really makes carrot cake shine. It felt like it was missing the signature element that makes the dessert so memorable. Overall, it’s a nice spot if you’re looking for some excellent cheesecake and don’t mind paying premium prices. For me, it landed in the middle—great quality in some areas, but not consistent enough across the board to rate higher"

Nel L

4 months ago

"I recently visited this bakery and was really impressed. The customer service was excellent—staff were friendly, attentive, and made me feel welcome from the moment I walked in. I decided to try the Napoleon cake, and it was absolutely delicious. The pastry layers were perfectly crisp, the cream was rich and smooth, and the balance of sweetness was just right. Overall, a wonderful experience that I’d happily recommend to anyone with a sweet tooth"

Ralph Y

4 months ago

"Stopped by Martha’s Country Bakery and got a slice of Triple Chocolate cake. The flavor was rich, with a nice balance of sweetness and cocoa bitterness. The cake was fresh and had a soft texture. I was pleased with it."

Kay N

5 months ago

"Not recommended. Berry Napoleon - the puff layer was so soft and soggy. Didn’t expect to have a soggy napoleon and was so disappointed. I was looking for a crunchy one. Ekmek - the kataifi at the bottom was very soggy. Expected to have a crunchy kataifi layer but was disappointed as well. Pecan Cheesecake - pecan was not crunchy. Taste of cheesecake was okay."